As someone who was a teen in the early to mid 2000’s, I’m always going to have a soft spot in my heart for celebrity fragrances. I had a bottle of Britney Spears Curious that I wore nonstop in 2006 (which doesn’t THAT just show my age). And it’s a love that I have carried well into adulthood. Which is why today, I thought it would be fun to do a ranking of the Sabrina Carpenter Sweet Tooth fragrance range. I own nearly all of them *See Em’s Note*. And it’s a range that I have a lot of strong opinions about having worn them over the last few years. Let’s get into it!
*Em’s Note* At the time of writing, Sweet Tooth Lemon Pie has not yet been released in Australia. I’ll give that one it’s own separate review when it does come out.
4) SABRINA CARPENTER SWEET TOOTH ME ESPRESSO
NOTES – Top: Espresso, Cappuccino, Cocoa. Middle: Biscuit, Jasmine, Vanilla Orchid. Base: Whipped Cream, Caramel, Amber
Yep, we are kicking this list off with the newest baby to hit Aussie shores. And in this case, it is a bad thing. I won’t lie, despite the incredibly polarising reaction this copped when it first launched in 2024, I was still so, so excited to try Me Espresso for myself. A coffee note in a fragrance is such a me thing, it should be inscribed into my DNA. But this is all kinds of wrong for me. The white florals clash with the espresso note so badly with my skin chemistry (I did think y’all were lying, but it does smell like grape soda to me). The only way I can describe it is that it smells cheap and fake. Like a espresso syrup that had some jasmine floating around the bottom, permeating the whole thing. It does get some points for having solid longevity, but that’s about it.Thank goodness I bought the 10ml. Because a bigger bottle is not in my future.
3) SABRINA CARPENTER SWEET TOOTH
NOTES – Top: Marshmallow, Chocolate, Candied Ginger, Bergamot. Middle: Madagascar Vanilla, Coconut, Jasmine. Base: Whipped Cream, Musk, Sugar, Cashmere Wood
My beef with this one is pretty well known on here (worst in beauty winner 2024). My stance on it has softened in my old age though. I said from the very beginning that this does smell absolutely incredible! My issue is that incredible smell doesn’t last at all. I feel like I have to use half the bottle just to have anything last on me. If you’re a fan of these notes, but want a beast level fragrance, I still heavily recommend the Billie Eilish Eilish 1 EDP. Same deal, but lasts forever on the skin.
2) SABRINA CARPENTER SWEET TOOTH CHERRY BABY
NOTES – Top: Cherry, Brown Sugar, Plum, Apple. Middle: Dark Chocolate, Red Poppy, Vanilla Orchid, Peony. Base: Musk, Cashmere Wood, Amber, Patchouli, Resin
Now we are getting into the fun ones. You look at the notes of this on paper and you swear it shouldn’t work. But for me, it absolutely does. It has such a delicious, juicy quality. With the Dark Chocolate and Musk adding a sensual note that stops it from smelling too juvenile. I also find that the newer Sweet Tooth released have a far better wear time than some of the older ones. I can still smell this on me after 8 hours of wear. Is this my favourite Cherry fragrance? No. But it’s still a total banger!
1) SABRINA CARPENTER SWEET TOOTH CARAMEL DREAM
NOTES – Top: Sugar, Almond Milk Orange, Freesia, Lemon. Middle: Dark Chocolate Vanilla, Orange Blossom. Orchid. Base: Caramel, Patchouli, Sandalwood, Musk, Amber
But by a sizable mile, Caramel Dream is my favourite of the bunch. I’m a sucker for a warm, slightly spicy, vanilla caramel perfume (maybe that should be embedded onto my DNA?). And Caramel Dream delivers that in spades! It’s zesty, spicy (I always pick up ginger when I wear this), warm, comforting, slightly gooey. This is one of my winter go to’s that I can chuck on and just adore. Plus, it’s 100% workplace safe for me. This is a must try for sure.
And that’s a wrap on my Sabrina Carpenter Perfume ranking! I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments. And as always, let me know what you’ve tried.
Cheers and love
Emily xo