Skip to content

Emmie's Beauty Life

Beauty in the Outback

Menu
  • Home
  • About Me
    • DISCLAIMER
  • Contact Me
Menu

Emmie Reviews – Trouble Maker Beauty Curl Theory Mascara

Posted on November 20, 2026November 19, 2026 by emmiesbeautylifeadmin

Sound the alarm, everyone! we have an all new drugstore brand here on Australian shores. That’s right, months after their successful UK launch, Trouble Maker Beauty is now available at Kmart and Target here in Australia. This is a range that promises fun, high quality makeup for a super affordable price. All are things that I love to see. I picked up a few products from the range (you’ll see me talk about some of them in my Bite Size Reviews next month).

But you know me at this point. When there is a new beauty range, I’m making an immediate beeline to the mascaras. I was actually surprised to see that there are quite a few in this range. Out of all of them, the Curl Theory Mascara was the one that caught my eyes and my lashes first. I love a fluttery, curled lash more than anything. And I knew I had to try it. I’ve spent the last few weeks using it behind the scenes. And I’m ready to share my thoughts. So, let’s get into it!

TROUBLE MAKER MAKEUP CURL THEORY CURLING MASCARA – $10.00 – kmart.com.au

Kicking us off with the packaging, the Curl Theory Mascara is housed in a sleek, two tone purple, cylindrical tube style packaging. There is some white detail on the tube. I think the little face on the handle is a lovely touch of whimsy to what is, admittedly, pretty basic packaging. Overall, there isn’t much to to say about it. Considering how affordable this mascara is. I’d be more shocked if the packaging was more extravagant. This is totally fine. The Curl Theory Mascara contains 7g of product.

It’s been more than a minute since I last had to roast a mascara brush. And the Curl Theory Mascara has one of the worst brushes I’ve seen for a little while. I’ll start with what I do like about it. I like that the wand is on the petite and slim side. I also like that the fiber bristles appear to be quite close together. Theoretically, this will help build up volume. But what the actual eff is up with the curve? It’s almost like when someone was pulling the wand out of the tube for the first time, they kinked it on the way out, looked at it and though ‘that’ll do’. I personally find this brush very difficult to use without making some kind of a mess on my lid. It’s difficult to angle for my eye shape. And I have been sorely tempted to steal my boss’s pliers so I can straighten it up again.

The formula for the Curl Theory Mascara is pretty basic and bare bones. Again, we are in super affordable territory, so I’m not expecting miracles. This formula uses a mix of copolymers and waxes. And I suspect, despite it not being advertised as such, that this is meant to be a tubing formula. If it is, I can’t say I’ve used a tubing formula quite like this one. I found it to be quick thick and almost sticky to the touch (this will be important later). But it has a shockingly quick drydown. And you do need to scrape off the excess before every use as the product clings to the brush very easily. Notably around the tip of the wand. Every single time I’ve pulled this mascara out to use it, there has been a tail of product on the tip.

Putting on the Curl Theory Mascara was certainly an experience at first. First, I had to get the hang of using the brush without getting product all over myself. But once I did that and successfully managed to get two coats on, I won’t lie, I was pretty happy with the result that I got. Right off the bat, the mascara does live up to it’s name. The curl was definitely noticeable. I also got a good amount of lift and length from those two coats. I didn’t get a ton of volume, which did surprise me a little due to the formula being the way it is. But on that note, if I had to criticize this mascara (and I do, it’s written in my non existent contract), where I struggled the most with this mascara was with separation. It was almost like my lashes were magnetized, the way they wanted to stick together. And no amount of wriggling with the brush could get them to come apart. Overall, my first impressions is a mixed bag.

But now, we have to get to the all important wear test. And we might as well pack it up because this was something of a mess. We’ll start with the curl, which all but disappeared over the eight hours I was wearing this. I won’t lie, I did expect that to be the case. What I didn’t at all suspect was the transfer on the top part of my eye lid. It’s more noticeable on the right side of my face. But you can clearly see how the product has collected on the crease of my eye lid. Not as noticeable, but still noteworthy, is the flaking. Again, mostly on the right side of my face. But it is there. Lastly, I want to mention that this mascara is genuinely one of the most difficult mascaras I’ve tried to remove in a while. And it’s not even marketed as a waterproof formula. I soften it with oil but really have to scrub at my lashes to get the product completely off.

All in all, I have to say skip the Trouble Maker Beauty Curl Theory Mascara. The price might be right, but the wear and effect is so wrong for me. And I do not recommend it. Fortunately, there are plenty other mascaras in the Trouble Maker range. So, here’s hoping I can find a winner there. Have you tried the Trouble Maker Beauty Curl Theory Mascara? Let me know in the comments.

Cheers and love
Emily xo

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Me

 

Hi, I’m Emily. I’m 36 years old, based in North West Queensland, and I have a deep love for all things colourful and glittery. I started Emmie’s Beauty Life as an outlet to show Australia and the world that beauty isn’t just exclusive to the big city.

This blog is my home for makeup and skincare recommendations, reviews, hauls, and opinions on the beauty world.

Search

Categories

Find me here

  • Instagram

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

© 2026 Emmie's Beauty Life | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme